Frank Cqppa

The Risorgimento, culminating in the creation of the Italian Kingdom and the collapse of the temporal power, sparked a papal Counter-Risorgimento. The clash between Italian nationalism and the Catholic Church from the restoration of 1815 to the seizure of Rome in 1870 was threefold: ideological, political and religious. This chapter probes into the roots and the flowering of all three from the pontificate of Pius VII (1800-23) to that of Pius IX (1846-78). It explores the confrontation between the national Risorgimento and the Catholic Counter-Risorgimento - and the far-reaching consequences for both.

The conflict between the papacy and patriots in Italy had deep roots, as Lorenzo Valla in the fifteenth century and Niccolo Machiavelli in the sixteenth both challenged the temporal power. Nationalist suspicion of Rome transcended the literati during the course of the Napoleonic wars, when patriots confronted a church aligned to the conservative order. Although Pius VII rejected the invitation of Tsar Alexander of Russia (1801-25) to join his 'Holy Alliance', he adhered to much of its conservative, antinationalist programme. In turn, the allied powers viewed the pope as a fellow victim of Napoleonic aggression, returning most of his territory, with the exception of one part of Ferrara that was transferred to Austria, and Avignon and the Venaissan which were retained by Paris. Despite these favourable terms, in June 1815 Cardinal Ercole Consalvi, the papal secretary of state, issued a formal protest against these minor losses, seconded by Pius in September.1 It represented a precursor of Rome's unyielding stance in the ensuing nationalist age.

When the Spanish revolution of 1820 inspired upheaval elsewhere, the ultra-conservative party in the curia, the zelanti, pointed to the papacy as the antidote to revolution. Following the outbreak of a carbonari revolution in Naples early in July 1820, Consalvi opted for pragmatism rather than conservative solidarity.

1 Erasmo Pistolesi, Vita del Sommo Pontefice Pio VII, 4 vols. (Rome: F. Bourlie, 1824), vol. iv, pp. 106-16; Edward Hertslet, The map of Europe by treaty, 4 vols. (London: Butterworths, 1875-91), vol. i, pp. 267-8.

Was this article helpful?

0 0

Post a comment